Skip to content

Indonesia Football Tragedy: Questions Mount Over Police Response

Indonesian police were facing questions over their response after 125 people died in a stampede at a football stadium where officers fired teargas on angry fans invading the pitch.

The tragedy on Saturday night in the city of Malang, which also left 323 injured according to police, was one of the world’s deadliest sporting stadium disasters.

Arema FC supporters at the Kanjuruhan stadium stormed the pitch after their team lost 3-2 to the visiting team and bitter rivals, Persebaya Surabaya.

Witnesses said the fans flooded the Kanjuruhan Stadium pitch and demanded that Arema management explain why, after 23 years of undefeated home matches against Persebaya, this one ended in a defeat.

Police, who described the unrest as riots, said they tried to force fans to return to the stands and fired teargas after two officers were killed. Many of the victims were trampled or choked to death, according to police.

Arema football coach Javier Roca on Sunday said that fans had even “died in the arms of players,” after some of the team stayed on the pitch when the game ended.

“Returning from the press conference, I saw the tragedy,” he said, adding that “The boys passed by with victims in their arms.”

“I think the police overstepped their mark, even though I wasn’t out there and didn’t experience the outcome,” the Chilean coach told Spanish broadcaster Cadena Ser.

East Java police chief Nico Afinta defended the use of teargas.

“We have already done a preventive action before finally firing the teargas as [fans] began to attack the police, acting anarchically and burning vehicles,” he told a news conference early on Sunday.

Survivors described panicking spectators in a packed crowd as teargas rained down on them.

“Officers fired teargas, and automatically people were rushing to come out, pushing each other and it caused many victims,” 43-year-old spectator Doni, who declined to give his last name, told AFP.

“Nothing was happening, there was no riot. I don’t know what the issue was, they suddenly fired teargas. That’s what shocked me. Didn’t they think about kids, women?”

Damaged vehicles are seen inside the Kanjuruhan stadium in the aftermath of a fatal football stampede in Malang.

Photograph: Willy Kurniawan/Reuters“It was so terrifying, so shocking,” 22-year-old survivor Sam Gilang, who lost three friends in the crush, told AFP.

“People were pushing each other and … many were trampled on their way to the exit gate. My eyes were burning because of the teargas. I fortunately managed to climb up the fence and survived,” he said.

At least 125 people died, East Java deputy governor Emil Dardak told broadcaster Metro TV on Sunday evening, significantly lowering officials’ earlier death toll of 174 because of double counting.

“Some names were recorded twice because they had been referred to another hospital and were written down again,” he said, citing data collected by local police from 10 hospitals.

President Joko Widodo ordered an investigation into the tragedy, a safety review into all football matches and directed the country’s football association to suspend all matches until “security improvements” were completed.

A hospital director told local TV that one of the victims was five years old.

Video footage circulating on social media showed people shouting obscenities at police, who were holding riot shields and wielding batons.

Images taken from inside the stadium during the stampede additionally showed police firing teargas and people clambering over fences.

Amnesty International called for an investigation into why teargas was deployed in a confined space, saying it should only be used “when other methods have failed”.

Torched vehicles, including a police truck, littered the streets outside the stadium on Sunday morning. The stadium holds 42,000 people and authorities said it was a sell-out. Police said 3,000 people stormed the pitch.

Fan violence is an enduring problem in Indonesia, where deep rivalries have previously turned into deadly confrontations.

Persebaya Surabaya fans were not allowed to buy tickets for the game due to fears of violence.

However Indonesia’s coordinating minister for political, legal and security affairs, Mahfud MD, said organisers ignored a recommendation to print fewer tickets and hold the match in the afternoon instead of the evening.

On Sunday, Arema fans threw flower petals at the club’s lion mascot monument outside the stadium in tribute to the victims. And in Jakarta as many as 300 football fans gathered for a candlelit vigil outside the Gelora Bung Karno stadium carrying placards that read “Indonesian soccer in mourning” and “stop police brutality.”

Football supporters gather and pray. They lit candles as a tribute to the victims of the riots in a soccer match at the Jatidiri Stadium in Semarang. Photograph: Anadolu Agency/Getty ImagesThe football world mourned the disaster with Gianni Infantino, president of world football governing body FIFA, calling the stampede “a tragedy beyond comprehension”.

Manchester United and Barcelona posted tributes online while Spanish football clubs were to observe a minute’s silence. The Asian Football Confederation, as well as the German football association and Italy’s Serie A, all expressed their regret.

The Football Association of Indonesia (PSSI) was in touch with FIFA about the stampede and hoped to avoid sanctions, PSSI secretary general Yunus Yussi told a press conference.

Fifa’s safety guidelines prohibit the carrying of crowd control gas by police or stewards at pitchside.

Indonesia is due to host the 2023 FIFA U-20 World Cup from 20 May to 11 June, with 24 participating teams. As the host, the country automatically qualifies for the cup.

With Agence France-Presse and Associated Press

Featured News